A guy I worked with last year spent $60,000 on a marketing agency. A pretty good agency, too. And the process started the same way every agency starts: they sent him an intake form.
One of the questions:
“What makes you different from your competitors?”
He typed something: quality, relationships, caring about clients.
The agency took it and ran.
Six months later, he had a bunch of posts, a few videos, and a vague sense that something wasn’t clicking. Leads trickled. Sales stayed flat. The content looked professional, but it sounded like everyone else in his industry.
He blamed the agency. Changed agencies. Same thing happened.
Then he hired me, and I asked him a simple question:
“What makes you different?”
He told me the same thing: quality, relationships, care.
Then I said something he told me he’d never forget:
“Could anyone in your industry say the same thing?”
He paused. “Damn. You’re right.”
I told him…
The agency wasn’t bad at its job. They did exactly what he paid them to do. They took what he gave them and amplified it.
The problem was what he gave them to work with.
The Noise In - Noise Out Problem
When you hire an agency, a social media person, a content team, or anyone who “does marketing,” you’re handing them a megaphone. Whatever you put in their hands, they’re going to amplify and broadcast.
But most business owners hand over noise.
Not on purpose. They just don’t realize it.
And it’s not just the intake form. It’s everything they hand over: the website, the current marketing, the brochures, the one-pager, the “about us” page. Everything that talks about them is undifferentiated noise. It sounds exactly like their competitors. It says nothing specific. And the agency takes all of it and builds from there.
It’s the old saying: garbage in, garbage out.
But this time, it’s noise in, amplified noise out.
Marketing doesn’t create your message. Marketing amplifies it.
This is the part nobody talks about.
Most agencies don’t tell you, but they know from the jump when it’s going to be hard as hell to get results. They sign you up anyway and hope that volume and effort overcome the noise.
From their perspective, they have 50 other clients to amplify, and they’re not in the business of solving identity crises. Their job is to amplify what was given, and that’s what they do.
The Four Ways Noise Shows Up In Your Business
And here’s the alluring part: sometimes amplified noise works.
Shit, a broken clock is right twice a day. Some leads come in. Some deals close. The numbers move just enough to make the system seem fine.
But it’s not fine. It’s grinding for results that should be flowing.
I’ve noticed four areas where noise shows up.
- It shows up when hiring. Business owners bring on the agency, the consultant, the vendors. They build their thing. It looks gorgeous. But it doesn’t land. It doesn’t convert. It doesn’t scale. And the owner wonders why they keep cycling through partners who “just don’t get it.” ▶ They’re amplifying noise.
- It shows up in marketing. The website gets built. Ads get run. Content gets made. But it sounds like everyone else in the industry. It doesn’t convert relative to the experience and value being delivered. ▶ The business is better than the marketing suggests. But nobody knows it, because the marketing is noise.
- It shows up in sales. Prospects get on the phone and say, “So... what do you do again?” Multiple meetings happen. Sales teams over-explain. Deals that should close don’t, unless the owner jumps on the call to fix the pitch. ▶ That’s not a sales problem. That’s a signal problem.
- It shows up with the team. Owners tell me this all the time: “I don’t know what it is, but my team just doesn’t get it.” When someone asks what they do, they stumble. They list services. They say “it depends.” They can’t land a clear answer in 30 seconds. ▶ That’s not their fault. They’re repeating what they’ve heard. And what they’ve heard is noise dressed up as positioning.
The root cause is the same in all four places.
It isn’t what everyone is doing. It’s that everyone is amplifying noise.
The solution? Fix the signal.
The Three Things That Turn Noise Into Signal
Before spending another dollar on marketing, focus on three things to fix the signal.
I call it MOB:
- Clear Message
- Can’t Refuse Offer
- Compelling Brand Stories that Connect
Each one has a job.
Thanks for reading The Signal! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Message Informs:
Clear messaging answers questions. People walk away saying “I know” within just a few seconds:
- I know what you do
- I know who you work with
- I know what makes you different
- I know if this is for me
When the message is noise, people walk away confused. Or worse, they walk away thinking it’s the same as everyone else.
Here’s the test:
- If someone asks, “What makes you different?” and the answer reaches for words like “quality” or “relationships,” that’s not a message. That’s camouflage.
I worked with a consulting firm whose message was:
“Businesses grow exponentially when we apply scientific research to unlock the DNA of talent.”
What does that even mean?
We changed it to:
“Grow your people to grow your firm.”
Same company. Same service. Different message.
Conversions went up 300%.
Offer Ignites:
An offer isn’t a list of services. An offer should the thing that makes someone feel:
- I want this
- I’d be stupid to say no
Most businesses describe what they do like a menu. “We do strategy, coaching, and leadership development.”
That’s not an offer. That’s a list. Lists don’t ignite.
But a great offer does. It ignites and stokes emotion. It makes the value obvious. It wraps the outcome in a way that makes the prospect lean forward.
Here’s the crazy part: go to most service business websites right now.
- There’s no offer.
- There’s “book a consultation.”
- There’s “contact us.”
- There’s “schedule a discovery call.”
None of that is a can’t-refuse offer. That’s a request for someone’s time with no clear reason to give it.
When the offer ignites, pricing conversations get easier. Sales calls get shorter. People stop asking “what’s included?” because they already know what they’re getting is worth more than what they’re paying.
Brand Story Inspires:
Stories make it real. They make people believe:
- I believe this is possible
- I believe others have done it
- I believe I can have this too
Without stories, a message is just a claim. With stories, it’s a conviction. People stop saying “that sounds nice” and start saying “that could be me.”
Story isn’t the founder’s bio or an “about us” page. Story is the proof:
- The client transformations
- The testimonials with real faces and real words
- The case studies that show the before and after
- The emotional narratives that make the promise feel tangible.
I worked with Melting Pot. They wanted to talk about food.
I asked them: Why do people actually come here?
It wasn’t the fondue. People came to connect. Date nights. Celebrations. Quality time.
We changed the message from food to connection. Ran campaigns around “Daddy Daughter Date Night.” Made the offer and the stories about that.
The restaurants we represented had the highest sales growth across the entire national franchise.
Every case above had the same thing in common: a clear message, a can’t-refuse offer, and compelling stories that connect.
This is the ground-floor work. This is what a business needs to get right first. Because it’s the ground floor that impacts everything else.
What Changes When You Get The Signal Right
Once MOS is right, everything downstream becomes infinitely easier.
- Marketing works better.
- Sales work better.
- The team performs better.
- Hiring works better.
- The business goes further, faster.
This is the root that produces all the fruit. Get it wrong, and every dollar spent on growth is just amplifying noise. Get it right, and the same effort produces 2-3x the lift in attraction and conversion.
P.S. Don’t miss my MOB Blueprint series on how to build your Message, Offer, and Brand Story.
Happy hunting.
Out.. X